:: evaluation reports

The results of ImPACT's scanner evaluations have been published by the NHS PASA Centre for Evidence-based Purchasing (CEP), as evaluation reports. These allow purchasers to make decisions based on independent and detailed information. A list of reports is given in the table below with links to a summary of each report, which then links to the download page at the CEP archive website.

There are a number of types of report:

Problems linking to reports?

We are aware that there have problems with the links from our site to some of the published reports, due to the DH CEP website being moved. These should all now be working: if you continue to experiencing difficulties, you are best to go to the CEP archive web site and select the report from the list

Planned Reports

Please note: due to our current position there are currently no plans to carry out type testing of the 64 slice scanners currently on offer; nor the newest scanners such as 256-slice scanners and dual-source scanners.

If you are looking for dosimetric information, please also read our note regarding the CT Dosimetry tool, which you can find here.

Current reports

ImPACT reports are FREE to everybody involved in healthcare. All reports since 2002 are available for download from the CEP archive website, via the links on this page. Many of the reports published earlier than 2002 are available electronically but only for UK based users of the NHSnet.
Imaging Technology Updates contain round-ups of new systems, technology developments and innovative products.

Report name Publication date Report number
Advanced CT scanners for coronary angiography Mar-10 CEP 10043
Dyna-Vision mobile real-time remote patient monitor Mar-10 CEP 10037
NeuroLogica CereTom portable CT scanner Jan-10 CEP 09039
Multi-slice CT scanners Mar-09 CEP 08007
Wide-bore multi-slice CT scanners Mar-09 CEP 08029
128-320 slice CT scanners Mar-09 CEP 08028
64 slice CT scanners Mar-09 CEP 08027
32-40 slice CT scanners Mar-09 CEP 08026
16 slice CT scanners Mar-09 CEP 08025
CT scanner clinical applications software Mar-09 CEP 08024
CT perfusion imaging in the management of stroke and transient ischaemic attack Nov-08 CEP 08039
Wide bore CT scanner comparison report version 14 Mar-06 Report 06014
Six to ten slice CT scanner comparison report version 14 Mar-06 Report 06011
16 slice CT scanner comparison report version 14 Mar-06 Report 06012
32 - 64 slice CT scanner comparison report version 14 Mar-06 Report 06013
Siemens Somatom Sensation Open CT scanner technical evaluation Dec-05 Report 05071
GE LightSpeed RT CT scanner technical evaluation Nov-05 Report 05070
Wide bore CT scanner comparison report version 13 Jul-05 Report 05069
32 to 64 slice CT scanner comparison report version 13 Jul-05 Report 05068
Sixteen slice CT scanner comparison report version 13 Jul-05 Report 05067
Six to ten slice CT scanner comparison report version 13 Jul-05 Report 05066
CT scanner automatic exposure control systems Feb-05 Report 05016
Wide bore CT scanner comparison report version 12 Feb-05 Report 05015
Six to ten slice CT scanner comparison report version 12 Feb-05 Report 05014
Sixteen slice CT scanner comparison report version 12 Feb-05 Report 05013
32 to 64 slice CT scanner comparison report version 12 Feb-05 Report 05012
Philips Mx8000 IDT CT scanner technical evaluation Sep-04 MHRA 04099
Sixteen Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Version 11 Jun-04 MHRA 04115
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Version 11 Jun-04 MHRA 04114
Six to Ten Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Version 11 Jun-04 MHRA 04113
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Version 10 Mar-04 MHRA 04049
Sixteen Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Version 10 Mar-04 MHRA 04048
Six to Ten Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Version 10 Mar-04 MHRA 04047
Toshiba Aquilion 16 CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Mar-04 MHRA 04045
Siemens Sensation 16 CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Mar-04 MHRA 04037
GE LightSpeed 16 CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Feb-04 MHRA 04015
Six To Ten Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 9) Oct-03 MHRA 03123
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 9) Oct-03 MHRA 03122
Sixteen Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 9) Oct-03 MHRA 03121
Cardiac CT Scanning Sep-03 MHRA 03076
GE LightSpeed Ultra Advantage CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Jun-03 MHRA 03066
Dual Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 8) Feb-03 MDA 03023
Sixteen Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 8) Feb-03 MDA 03021
Single Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 8) Feb-03 MDA 03022
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 8) Feb-03 MDA 03020
Six To Ten Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 8) Feb-03 MDA 03019
Philips ACQSIM CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Aug-02 MDA 02099
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 7) Jul-02 MDA 02061
Dual Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 7) Jul-02 MDA 02060
Eight and Sixteen Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v.7) Jul-02 MDA 02059
Single Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 7) Jul-02 MDA 02058
Multi-Slice CT Scanners: Technology Update No.1 2nd Edition Mar-02 MDA 02024
Dual Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 6) Mar-02 MDA 02023
Eight and Sixteen Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v.6) Mar-02 MDA 02022
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 6) Mar-02 MDA 02021
Single Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report (v. 6) Mar-02 MDA 02020
GE LightSpeed / LightSpeed Plus CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Dec-01 MDA 01159
Siemens Somatom Volume Zoom CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Dec-01 MDA 01155
Marconi Mx8000 / Philips Mx8000 CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Dec-01 MDA 01154
Toshiba Aquilion Multi CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Dec-01 MDA 01153
Four Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Sep-01 MDA 01050
Dual Slice CT Scanner comparison Report Sep-01 MDA 01049
Single Slice CT Scanner Comparison Report Sep-01 MDA 01048
ImPACT Technology Update No. 1: Multi-Slice CT Scanners Mar-00 MDA/00/23
Comparison of the Imaging Performance of CT Scanners, Issue 12 Mar-00 MDA/00/11
Real Time CT & CT Fluoroscopy Mar-00 MDA/00/10
IGE HiSpeed FX/i CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Oct-99 MDA/99/65
Toshiba Xpress GX CT Scanner Technical Evaluation Aug-99 MDA/99/41
A Technical Assessment of the Philips Tomoscan M Computed Tomography Scanner May-99 MDA/99/34
SmartBeam and SmartScan features on the IGE HiSpeed CT/i Scanner Oct-98 MDA/98/69
Siemens: Somatom Plus 4 "Expert" & "Power" CT Scanners with "Lightning" UFC solid state detectors: Technical Evaluations Oct-98 MDA/98/67
Siemens: Somatom Plus 4 "Expert" & "Power" CT Scanners with both "Quantillarc" or "Lightning" detectors: User Evaluations Oct-98 MDA/98/66
Philips Medical Systems: Tomoscan AV Expander CT Scanner: Technical Evaluation Aug-98 MDA/98/53
Comparison of the Imaging Performance of CT Scanners: Issue 11 May-98 MDA/98/34
Type Testing of CT Scanners: Methods and Methodology for Assessing Imaging Performance and Dosimetry Apr-98 MDA/98/25
MDA's market guide for purchasers of diagnostic imaging equipment 1998 Apr-98 MDA/98/24
A User Assessment of the Elscint Twin series CT Scanners: incorporating the Twin II, Twin, Twin flash and Twin RTS Apr-98 MDA/98/23
A Technical Assessment of the Elscint CT-Twin flash Computerised Tomography Scanner Apr-98 MDA/98/22
A User Assessment of the Philips Medical Systems AV Series CT Scanners Feb-98 MDA/98/11

:: Printed evaluation reports

Printed reports are not currently available.